If you’re on the hunt for a reliable used car, Consumer Reports has narrowed down the seven best options, balancing reliability, safety, and performance across various budgets and preferences. Whether you’re after fuel efficiency, cargo space, or a sporty drive, there’s something for everyone on this list.

1. 2016 Mazda6 — Sporty and Stylish

The 2016 Mazda6 is a midsize sedan that offers a thrilling drive with its responsive four-cylinder engine and sharp handling. It’s not just about performance — the upscale interior and 32 mpg combined fuel economy make it a practical choice, too. The infotainment system got an upgrade this year, along with improved cabin insulation.

Key Features:

• 32 mpg combined
• Forward collision warning and blind spot monitoring available
• Sporty handling and upscale interior

2. 2018 Toyota Corolla — Reliable and Budget-Friendly

Known for its bulletproof reliability, the 2018 Toyota Corolla offers a smooth ride, excellent fuel economy (32 mpg overall), and a surprisingly spacious cabin for a compact car. Toyota’s TSS-P safety suite, which includes automatic emergency braking and lane departure warning, became standard in 2017 — making this model year a smart buy.

Key Features:

• 32 mpg combined
• Toyota Safety Sense-P suite standard
• Spacious back seat

3. 2016 Honda CR-V — Practical and Spacious

For those needing extra room, the 2016 Honda CR-V delivers. It’s a versatile compact SUV with a 2.4-liter engine and a CVT transmission, providing smooth power delivery and 24 mpg overall. Ample cargo space and Honda’s legendary reliability make this CR-V a standout.

Key Features:

• 24 mpg combined
• Spacious cargo area
• Strong safety ratings

4. 2019 Toyota Camry Hybrid — Exceptional Fuel Economy

If fuel efficiency is a priority, the 2019 Toyota Camry Hybrid is tough to beat with an impressive 52 mpg overall in the LE trim. Alongside its efficiency, the Camry Hybrid offers a smooth ride, advanced safety tech, and a roomy interior, making it an excellent choice for daily commuting.

Key Features:

• 52 mpg combined (LE trim)
• Standard safety features like adaptive cruise control
• Smooth ride and spacious cabin

5. 2021 Kia Sportage — Modern and Comfortable

The 2021 Kia Sportage delivers modern styling, a comfortable interior, and a host of tech features. Updates in 2020 brought a larger infotainment screen and enhanced safety features like automatic emergency braking. It’s a solid choice for those seeking a balance between value and comfort.

Key Features:

• Modern tech features
• Solid ride comfort
• Strong warranty coverage

6. 2018 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid — Fuel-Efficient and Reliable

The 2018 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid offers 8 mpg more than its gas-only counterpart, combining efficiency and practicality. It features Toyota’s reputation for reliability, a smooth ride, and impressive cargo capacity — perfect for eco-conscious drivers who need space.

Key Features:

• Improved efficiency over the gas model
• Spacious cargo area
• Low maintenance costs

7. 2020 Mazda CX-9 — Fun and Family-Friendly

Rounding out the list is the 2020 Mazda CX-9. It blends sporty handling with family-friendly features like second-row captain’s chairs and a luxurious interior. The turbocharged engine adds a punch, while the refreshed safety tech offers added peace of mind.

Key Features:

• Turbocharged performance
• Upscale interior
• Updated safety features

Quick Comparison Table

Final Thoughts

Whether you prioritize fuel efficiency, cargo space, or a fun driving experience, these seven used cars stand out for their reliability, safety features, and overall value. Consumer Reports’ recommendations offer peace of mind, ensuring you’re getting a vehicle that’s been thoroughly vetted and praised by real owners.

Check out more in the Reviews & Ratings section.